Deluxe Only!
| Ribbon (White, Red, Blue) | | From the Cooking Contest |
| Teddy Bear | | From the ball-tossing game |
| Tiara | | From the Flower Queen contest |
| Signet | | Defeating the Wizard in the Dungeon |
| Mystical Whatsit Deluxe Only! | | Finding the secret of the ball-tossing game |
| Amber |  | Amethyst |  |
| Diamond |  |
Emerald |  |
| Crystal Orb |  |
Rainbow Crystal |  |
| Sapphire |  |
Night Stone |  |
| Flower |  |
Iron Nails |  |
| Stick |  |
Ribbon |  |
| Rocks |  |
Tooth |  |
| Acorn |  |
Leather Scrap |  |
| Dry Bones |  |
Egg |  |
| Mushroom |  |
| Fallen Star |  |
Runestone |  |
Fairy Dust |  |